The Status of Women in Arabia before Islam

While researching the social and literary milieu of pre-Islamic Arabia, I happened upon Robert Hoyland's Arabia and the Arabs from the Bronze Age to the Coming of Islam. Hoyland is an excellent scholar, currently a research fellow and professor of Islamic history at Oxford. Of note is his section discussing women in pre-Islamic Arabia (128-134) where he surveys pre-Islamic records and early Islamic records of pre-Islamic times.



Being a former Muslim, I have been told since birth that Islam brought freedom and rights to women who had none. This claim is normally made when Islam's injunctions concerning women are brought under scrutiny. When asked why Muhammad considered women intellectually deficient, why a Muslim woman's testimony is worth half that of a Muslim man's, why Muslim women have far more stringent procedures to acquire divorces than men, etc., the answer has often been "Arab women had no rights before Muhammad. Girls were often buried alive as soon as they were born! Islam vindicated women from brutal oppression."

That Islam abolished the practice of female infanticide may very well be true (although evidence seems to indicate that infanticide was practiced on both sexes). But the claim that Arab women had no rights before Muhammad is wholly untenable. The records show that there was great diversity among Arab tribes, and that the rights of women before Islam often exceeded those accorded to them by Islam. 

The following are facts regarding the status of women in various Arabian tribes before Islam:
  • There is evidence of matrilineal tribes, where lineage was determined through women. Children were reckoned as belonging to their mothers, and not a male progenitor. (129)
  • Women had the right to easily divorce their husbands such that their husbands had to leave the homes, and not the women. A woman could achieve this simply by turning her tent around. (130)
  • Women were able to:
    • Marry multiple men;
    • Contract men in temporary marriage for the sake of producing offspring; (131)
    • Commission inscriptions;
    • Make offerings to their deities;
    • Act as administrative officers;
    • Construct public buildings;
    • Erect tombs;
    • Maintain considerable financial independence;
    • Be the subjects of statues and funerary reliefs;
    • Become overlords (132)
    • And become the guardians of religious confederations. (133)
I'm not commenting on the propriety of these rights and privileges, nor am I insinuating that they are better than what Islam brought. I'm making an observation of simple fact: these are instances of Arab women having privileges and rights, often far greater than those accorded by Islam.

Also, one could argue that Islam provides a better social system than those that existed in pre-Islamic Arabia; such a position is untouched by these facts. However, to argue that Islam rescued women from a universal state of oppression would be to ignore the available evidence.

Assessment: Contrary to a great deal of polemics, pre-Islamic Arabia, a socially diverse climate, often accorded women greater rights and privileges than those they have under Islam.

17 comments:

  1. the very best single source on the topic of how islam affected women is leila ahmed's excellent article "women and the advent of islam" which appeared in signs, volume 11 number four 1986.

    everyone dedicated to speaking truth about islam must read this article.

    here is a link to the first page on jstor: http://www.jstor.org/pss/3174138

    ReplyDelete
  2. I always wondered why Muhammad's first wife, Khadijah, was a very wealthy woman if women before the advent of Islam had no rights and freedom.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Yes. Khadija may Allah be pleased with her was very rich but she is an exception. Only women from high class societies can work and seek knowledge but when Islam comes, it makes knowledge a duty upon every Muslim, man or woman.

      Delete
  3. Thats really intresting... So u claim that Women before Islam had much more rights in Arab world before Islam than after Islam?? :-)
    And Really I find it more intresting that u studied only this book and concluded with facts that are not even known and accepted by Christian scholars themselves..Waiting for ur answer... Thanks

    ReplyDelete
  4. Contrary to ur blog Nabeel wanna show people here some more facts... About women status....
    History of Disgrace

    From the annals of disgrace that humanity has seen is a woman being treated like she was not even human.
    The Greeks said regarding a woman: She is like a poisonous tree and she is evil from the Satan. She may be sold like any merchandise.
    The Romans said: She does not have a soul. They would torture women by pouring boiling oil on them, or dragging them using horses.
    The Chinese said: She is cursed water that washes away good fortune. A Chinese man would have the right to bury his wife alive. If a man were to die his wife would be passed on as inheritance.
    The Indians said: A woman is worse than death, hell, and fire. A woman doesn’t have the right to live after her death, but she was required to be burned along with his corpse.
    The Persians deemed it permissible to marry female relatives without exception. A Persian husband could command his wife to die.
    The Jews said: A woman is a curse because she is the cause of sin and temptation. She is impure during her menses. It is permissible for her father to sell her.
    The Christians: The French held a discussion in the year 568 A.D. some of the issues discussed were; Is a woman a human or not? Does she have soul or not? If she has a soul is it a human soul or an animal soul? And if it is a human soul then is it equal to a man’s soul or is it below a man’s soul?

    Finally after deliberation they came to the conclusion that she is human, but she was created to serve man.

    The Parliament at the time of Henry VIII (King of England) decided that it is unlawful for women to read the New Testament (Bible) because she is impure.
    The Arabs before Islam: hated women more than death. They were buried alive or thrown into an abandoned well.

    ReplyDelete
  5. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Women_in_Arab_societies#Economic_role
    Just for enriching ur knowledge brother I suggest u must atleast consult other historicans and study about this through wikipedia and other articles and books.... U will find things different....Sincerely

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. brother he is selling him in the name of quarashi---but abu jehel was a quarashi.he is selling his past,selling his soul for the money.nice go on

      Delete
  6. last thing that nobody says or said that before ISLAM women were not permitted to live... there were womens living good and having some rights as u mentioned but there number was lower then nothing... So u can' count them as a status of women at that time... As u said there were cases of women having rights u mentioned but when we say status it means a vast number...NoT FEW... Thanks

    ReplyDelete
  7. I suggest people go and see the last slide from this slideshow
    http://www.scientificamerican.com/slideshow.cfm?id=forgotten-history-muslim-scientists

    to know that the first operating university in the world was established by muslim women, and for your info before islam arabs used to kill female at their birth

    http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Women_in_Arab_societies#Arab_women_before_Islam

    Thank you @OmranAntar

    ReplyDelete
  8. What an amazing post about women in the pre-Islamic era! This is a subject so rarely written about, and one very deserving of public and in particular, Western attention.

    ReplyDelete
  9. This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.

    ReplyDelete
  10. You make so many great points here that I read your article a couple of times. Your views are in accordance with my own for the most part. This is great content for your readers. divorce attorney charleston sc

    ReplyDelete
  11. Followers of Muhammad are utterly prejudiced and biased calling pre-islamic as "jahaliya" ignorance.
    Khadijas financial independence came from the Jahaliya period, and in fact post-Islam no other female had this.

    ReplyDelete
  12. Followers of Muhammad are utterly prejudiced and biased calling pre-islamic as "jahaliya" ignorance.
    Khadijas financial independence came from the Jahaliya period, and in fact post-Islam no other female had this.

    ReplyDelete
  13. Women are viewed differently and depends on the culture they are living with. But unlike before, women are more stronger and empower these days, unlike the women in the old times listed in the stories via EssayEmpire review, which are viewed as helpless and weak.

    ReplyDelete